Have you been disadvantaged in a hotel, shop or restaurant compared to others just because you belong to a certain nationality or have a darker skin colour? Are there situations where a business can afford to do this? How far does freedom of enterprise and autonomy of will for entrepreneurs extend and what can already be considered discrimination against consumers? We will explain what discrimination is and how to distinguish between direct discrimination and indirect discrimination.
Discrimination is unequal treatment on the basis of prohibited grounds such as race, nationality, gender, age, disability or sexual orientation. In consumer protection, it is crucial that everyone has access to goods and services on equal terms. Discrimination can be direct or indirect.
If we are about to enter into a contractual relationship, for example to grant a lease or make a sale, autonomy of the will generally applies, including the free choice of the contractual partner. At the same time, however, the Consumer Protection Act provides us with a prohibition on consumer discrimination, according to which the seller may not discriminate against the consumer when selling products or providing services. The Anti-Discrimination Act also prohibits discrimination in, inter alia, matters of access to goods and services, including housing, when offered to the public or in the provision of such services, with the proviso that an individual has the right to equal treatment and not to be discriminated against in legal relations covered by the Act.
If there is a conflict between two different rights, then they must be weighed against each other in some way to determine which one to give priority to. First of all, it should be examined whether the person has any objective reason for treating the different subjects differently and there should be a comparison of the weight of the fundamental rights in conflict. It must be said that the outcome may vary considerably from case to case depending on the circumstances.
Tip: Do you know your basic rights and what to do if they are violated? We have written a detailed procedure in our article.
Don’t leave anything to chance and use the services of an attorney. We will conduct a careful analysis of your case and take care of the preparation of the lawsuit and representation in court, where we will vigorously enforce your rights.
I'd like some help in writing a lawsuit
Let us first define what consumer discrimination is. We understand it as commercial practices that unjustifiably favour some consumers over others in similar transactions or services – the aim of the prohibition of discrimination in the field of consumer protection is therefore to conclude identical contracts on identical terms.
The theory distinguishes between two types of discrimination – direct discrimination and indirect discrimination.
Tip: Do you know your basic rights and what to do if they are violated? We have written a detailed procedure in our article.
According to the conclusions and regular surveys of the Czech Trade Inspection Authority, cases of discrimination still occur, although the detected and proven cases range from a few or small tens of cases each year. However, it is clear that not everything is detected and the problem is in fact much bigger. In particular, the problem is the discriminatory behaviour of some sellers towards foreign visitors. There are still cases of discrimination against consumers of Roma ethnicity, which still occur in some localities. According to the conclusions of the CTIA, there were also cases of different prices for the same services or discrimination on the grounds of age.
Discrimination against consumers manifests itself in various forms. Among the most common are:
It is because of these practices that the Czech Trade Inspection Authority carries out regular inspections. Although the number of detected cases remains low, it is likely that the true extent of the problem is much greater.
If you have been discriminated against, you have the right to seek redress. You can demand:
Each case is judged by a court, which takes into account what is still within the law and what is already discriminatory.
The Constitutional Court has also contributed its bit to the mill in defining what is or is not discrimination against consumers in the controversial Brioni case. A decision by the Czech Trade Inspection Authority and a number of courts, including the Supreme Court, found that a hotel operator had committed discrimination by requiring Russian citizens to sign a declaration that they did not agree with the annexation of Crimea as a condition for staying in the hotel. The Constitutional Court sided with the complainant in a rather controversial ruling at the time. In doing so, it referred both to the autonomy of the will and to the fact that the content of individual rights may differ in certain situations. In its reasoning, it used, among other things, a literary reference to Dr Galen from Karel Čapek’s The White Sickness (Galen refused to provide his medicine to people who could stop the war, thus applying a double standard). The finding was received very ambiguously and drew an indignant response from both the non-expert public and the legal community.
Similar passions have been aroused by the possibility of exercising free will when one wants to enter into a lease agreement as a homeowner. The views of state institutions may differ in this respect. Some court decisions have established that a private landlord has far fewer limits on the autonomy of the will and may, for example, choose whether (not) to enter into a contract with a member of a certain group of people (disabled, Roma, homosexuals). The Litoměřice court concluded this in its 2015 judgment. However, it added in the same breath that, for example, real estate brokers are subject to completely different criteria in this respect. The latter would no longer be allowed to make such a choice. Not to mention hotels.
It should be added that the former ombudsman and then deputy ombudsman, Anna Šabatová, was far from benevolent in this respect. According to her , it is clearly impossible to deny someone access to housing simply because they belong to a certain ethnic group.
Consumer discrimination is unequal treatment on the basis of prohibited grounds such as race, nationality or age, and can be direct (e.g. refusal of service because of ethnic origin) or indirect (rules that indirectly disadvantage certain groups). The Czech Trade Inspection Authority regularly monitors discriminatory practices such as dual pricing, ethnic surcharges or age discrimination, while their true extent remains undetected. Consumers have the right to seek redress, including an apology or financial compensation. Cases such as the controversial decision of the Constitutional Court regarding discrimination against Russian citizens show the clash between the autonomy of the will of entrepreneurs and the prohibition of discrimination, with courts assessing each case individually.
Need help with filing a lawsuit or representing yourself in court? Whether the litigation is just beginning or the case is well underway, we can help you with everything. We will conduct a thorough analysis, assess your realistic chances and suggest a course of action. All this within 48 hours of ordering our services.
Ondřej is the attorney who came up with the idea of providing legal services online. He's been earning his living through legal services for more than 10 years. He especially likes to help clients who may have given up hope in solving their legal issues at work, for example with real estate transfers or copyright licenses.
In person and online. Just choose the appropriate service or opt for an independent consultation when you are unsure.
