Recovery of damages in adhesion proceedings

JUDr. Ondřej Preuss, Ph.D.
22. August 2024
6 minutes of reading
6 minutes of reading
Criminal law

Have you been the victim of a crime and been harmed? Are you thinking of pursuing it in criminal proceedings? What is an adhesion procedure and how exactly does it work? We take a closer look at this in our article.

vymáhání náhrady škody, adhezní řízení

Adhesion proceedings as part of the criminal process

Adhesion proceedings are a specific part of the criminal process that allows victims to seek compensation for damages directly in the context of criminal proceedings against the perpetrator. This mechanism is particularly important if you have suffered an injury and want to be compensated without having to pursue a separate civil case. The application must be filed no later than the moment the court starts the main trial.

The advantage of the adhesion procedure is that it runs concurrently with the criminal proceedings, which means that you do not have to wait for the criminal proceedings to finish. This way, your situation can be resolved more efficiently in some cases without having to take further legal action in civil matters.

Adhesion proceedings are applicable to a wide range of crimes, from property crimes, such as theft or damage to another person’s property, to more serious crimes, including physical assault or other forms of crime that result in personal injury or property damage.

On the other hand, far from all damages (or only a small percentage of them) can be dealt with in this way. Indeed, a necessary condition is that a crime has been committed which will be proven in the proceedings. Very often, however, the damage is caused by some carelessness or inattention, but no criminal law is violated. In such cases, only civil proceedings or out-of-court settlements are appropriate.

Moreover, it is important to note that in order to succeed in an adhesion procedure, the victim must prove not only that the damage occurred, but also that there is a direct causal link between the criminal act and the damage. The burden of proof lies with the victim, which means that it is his responsibility to produce sufficient evidence to support his claims.

It is important to distinguish adhesion proceedings from situations where several cases are joined for a joint trial. In such cases, there is no hierarchical relationship between the different proceedings, and therefore the court may proceed to adjudicate the other claims once one part has been resolved. In contrast, in adhesion proceedings, the procedure is entirely dependent on the main criminal proceedings; at the conclusion of the latter, the adhesion proceedings end. If the claim has not been satisfied in the adhesion proceedings, a new motion must be filed to enforce it.

Are you solving a similar problem?

We provide you with a fast and easy access to justice

We know that the situation of victims and victims of crime in criminal proceedings is very challenging. We can help you map out your situation and explain your rights and options in a clear way. We will write a criminal complaint, guide you through the criminal proceedings and support you in court.

I want to consult

  • When you order, you know what you will get and how much it will cost.
  • We handle everything online or in person at one of our 4 offices.
  • We handle 8 out of 10 requests within 2 working days.
  • We have specialists for every field of law.
Tip na článek

Tip: Have you been the victim of a crime and suffered damages? What are the defence options under Czech law and when can you claim damages in criminal proceedings? We have looked at this in more detail in our separate article.

What are the advantages of claiming damages in adhesion proceedings?

Claiming damages in criminal proceedings offers a number of advantages to victims that should not be overlooked. For example, it can bring a form of moral satisfaction to the victim, which can be brought about by an acknowledgement of the perpetrator’s guilt in an official court decision. This satisfaction is often crucial to the victims’ psychological recovery.

Adhesion proceedings also allow that if the court finds it necessary to take further evidence, such as requiring expert evidence, the costs of this evidence are paid by the state, not the victim. This feature can significantly reduce the financial burden on victims who would otherwise have to bear these costs themselves.

However, it is important to know that each case is specific and may require a different approach. Therefore, it is essential to consult with a qualified attorney who is experienced in criminal law and adhesion proceedings about your situation. An attorney will not only provide personalized advice, but will also help you build and defend your claim, which can greatly increase your chances of success in litigation. Professional legal representation is particularly important when dealing with complex legal issues or high value damages.

What can be claimed in an adhesion procedure?

  1. Property Damages: The victim may seek compensation for damages caused by the crime. This includes direct costs such as the cost of repairs, compensation for destroyed or stolen property. This can also include loss of earnings. If the crime has caused the victim to lose income, they can claim compensation for what they would have earned if the crime had not happened.
  2. Non-pecuniary damage: Refers to damages that are not directly measurable in terms of financial expenditure, such as pain, social distress, mental anguish or reputational damage.
  3. Unjust enrichment: If the perpetrator has enriched himself at the expense of the victim without legal justification, restitution may be sought.
Tip na článek

Tip: Road accidents are one of the most common situations in which we deal with compensation for damages, either as the injured party or as the person who caused the damage. What are the relationships between the parties involved and how does the insurance company get involved? What can you claim and how to proceed in such situations?

How does the court proceed in adhesion proceedings?

If the accused is found guilty of a crime and the damage caused by the crime is proven, the court may award the victim compensation, either in full or in part, depending on the specifics of the case. The court therefore decides on compensation in the context of the guilty verdict in the main criminal proceedings.

If all the conditions are met and there is a clear causal link between the act and the damage, the accused will be liable for compensation. However, if the evidentiary proceedings would require extensive evidence that would significantly delay the trial, the court may decide that the victim should pursue his or her claim in civil litigation or before another competent authority. In practice, it is often the case that the court will refer the victim to civil court proceedings in order to avoid complications in the criminal process.

If the crime is not proven and the proceedings are dismissed, the claim for compensation is also extinguished.The decision on compensation can be challenged using the standard legal remedies available in criminal proceedings.

Sdílejte článek


Are you solving a similar problem?

Representation of the victim in criminal proceedings

If you are a victim in criminal proceedings, then you have special procedural rights that are good to know. In this situation, it pays to be represented by an attorney.

I want you to help

Author of the article

JUDr. Ondřej Preuss, Ph.D.

Ondřej is the attorney who came up with the idea of providing legal services online. He's been earning his living through legal services for more than 10 years. He especially likes to help clients who may have given up hope in solving their legal issues at work, for example with real estate transfers or copyright licenses.

Education
  • Law, Ph.D, Pf UK in Prague
  • Law, L’université Nancy-II, Nancy
  • Law, Master’s degree (Mgr.), Pf UK in Prague
  • International Territorial Studies (Bc.), FSV UK in Prague

You could also be interested in

We can also solve your legal problem

In person and online. Just choose the appropriate service or opt for an independent consultation when you are unsure.

Google reviews
4.9
Facebook reviews
5.0
5 200+ people follow our Facebook
140+ people follow our X account (Twitter)
140+ people follow our LinkedIn
 
We can discuss your problem online and in person

You can find us in 4 regional towns

Quick contacts

+420 775 420 436
(Mo–Fri: 8–18)
We regularly comment on events and news for the media