Quick summary
- Damage to another’s property is typically an intentional crime, not automatically every occurrence of damage.
- The amount of the damage, the intent of the perpetrator, and the ownership of the property are the main determinants.
- Some cases end up as misdemeanors, while others can lead to jail time.
- In practice, quick documentation of the damage, photos, witnesses and an estimate for repairs are often key.
- In addition to criminal proceedings, the victim may also seek compensation for damages.
Damage to another’s property is generally a criminal offence if the perpetrator intentionally destroys, damages or renders useless another’s property and causes damage that is at least not negligible. The decisive factors are, in particular, the intent, the amount of the damage and whether it was actually someone else’s property. Negligent conduct is more often dealt with outside criminal law. In practice, therefore, it depends on the prompt securing of evidence, the quantification of the damage and the correct procedural procedure.
If you have experienced damage to property, we can help you assess whether it makes sense to file a criminal complaint, how to quantify the damage and how to protect your rights in criminal and civil proceedings.
What is damage to property?
Vandalism, graffiti on walls, scratching someone else’s car, or painting a Ukrainian flag on the pavement. This is also what acts that are characterised as criminal damage to foreign property can look like under Czech law. According to legal theory, what does such a crime consist of?
In legal terms, damage to another’s property is a deliberate act leading to the destruction, damage or rendering useless of another’s property. The simultaneous condition is the commission of at least a not insignificant damage (except when someone damages the foreign object by spraying, painting or describing it with paint or other substance).
Tip for article
“The offender shall be punished by imprisonment for two to eight years if he causes substantial damage by such an act.” Such sentences can also be found in the Criminal Code. What is major, substantial or not minor damage? How are the limits of damage set in criminal proceedings and why is the specific amount of damage caused not set for each act? This is discussed in a separate article.
From the point of view of law, the basic prerequisite for classifying an act as a criminal offence of damage to another’s property is that the property actually belongs to someone else. In cases where property relations are unclear, for example in the case of unsettled matrimonial property, the legal qualification may be more complex. For example, the courts dealt with a similar case in the case of a man who destroyed the front door of his ex-wife’s house, claiming that it was not his ex-wife’s door but his own, as he had bought and installed it himself. If the court had suggested that it was not in fact someone else’s property, then the offence could not even have been committed. However, that did not happen in this case.
Are you solving a similar problem?
Are you considering filing a criminal complaint?
Have you been a victim or witness to a crime, are you considering filing a criminal complaint? We can advise you on how to proceed. We will protect your rights quickly, efficiently and profitably.
I want to consult
- When you order, you know what you will get and how much it will cost.
- We handle everything online or in person at one of our 6 offices.
- We handle 8 out of 10 requests within 2 working days.
- We have specialists for every field of law.
Example: the Kaputin association recently gained media attention for its happening in which its members painted a Ukrainian flag on the grounds of the apartment complex of the Enterprise for Administration of Property Abroad of the Chancellery of the President of the Russian Federation. By their action they wanted to express their support for the Russian-invaded Ukraine and at the same time they wanted to draw attention to the issue of Russian-owned buildings in the Czech Republic, where there are increasing cases of numerous contradictions with the law and contracts.
However,the Police of the Czech Republic assessed the actions of the participants in the happening as a criminal act of damaging property and charged seven of the participants in the event. One of the essential reasons for this qualification was the estimation of the damage caused on the basis of an expert opinion of CZK 44 891 (the Property Management Company itself estimated the damage caused at more than CZK 100 000). The fact that the building was in a conservation area should also have been an aggravating factor. The association itself assessed its act as socially beneficial, which, in its view, did not fulfil one of the essential elements of the offence, i.e. its social harmfulness. The association also documented that the painting could be easily removed using a high-pressure cleaner and water and that the pavement was not damaged in any way. Ultimately, the court concluded that the painting of the Ukrainian flag in this case was not a criminal offence and the case ended in a misdemeanour.
Tip for article
Did a skier hit you on the slopes and injure you? Your neighbour’s dog pounced on you and bit right into your new leather briefcase? Or did a distracted driver scrape the side of your car while parking at the supermarket? What are you entitled to and what are the principles of compensation in a personal injury claim?
What is the limit of damages and what about intent or negligence
The criminal offence of damaging someone else’s property is regulated in the Czech legal system in Section 228 of the Criminal Code. In order to assess whether a criminal offence has been committed, it is important to consider several key aspects:
Intent versus negligence: under the Czech Criminal Code, intent of the perpetrator is required for the commission of the offence of damage to property. It is therefore a deliberate offence, although indirect intent is sufficient (where the perpetrator knows that the way he acts may lead to the commission of the offence and is aware of this in case it actually happens). The perpetrator’s intent must include the fact that the property is someone else’s.
It is in contentious cases that it is how the offender’s intent is described, to whom the thing actually belonged and how the damage is quantified that is crucial. If you are unsure whether to file a criminal complaint or to deal with the matter more as compensation, it is worth having a lawyer assess the situation beforehand. In practice, a first legal analysis will often show what course of action has a realistic chance of success and what evidence needs to be secured quickly.
In the case of significant damage or large-scale damage, the criminal rate increases. The specific definition of the different levels of damage is as follows:
- not insignificant damage: at least CZK 10 000,
- major damage: at least CZK 100 000,
- substantial damage: at least CZK 1 000 000,
- major damage: at least CZK 10 000 000.
Penalties for damaging other people’s property
The penalties for damage to property vary according to the severity of the case and, as mentioned above, the amount of damage. The mildest variant of the offence and causing not insignificant damage can lead to imprisonment for up to one year, prohibition of activity or forfeiture of the property.
Qualifying offences include either the possibility of causing substantial damage, or committing the offence on the property of a witness, expert or interpreter for the performance of his or her duty, or committing the offence on the property of another because of his or her actual or perceived race, membership of an ethnic group, nationality, political opinion, religion or because he or she is actually or perceived to be non-religious, social group, age, gender, sexual orientation, disability and, in general, membership of another group of persons. Also, a situation where the injured party enjoys protection under another legal provision leads to a possible imprisonment of six months to three years.
The most serious penalty is imprisonment for two years to six years if the act causes damage on a large scale.
Tip for article
We have dealt withthe offence and its features in detail in our article.
The most common cases of damage to foreign property in practice
The most common cases of damage to foreign property in practice are as follows:
- Vandalism: this is the deliberate damage to public and private property, such as graffiti on walls, damage to park benches or breaking windows.
- Damage to cars: people often settle scores with each other through their cars – a scratched car with a nickel, slashed tyres are the most common examples.
- Damage to personal items such as clothing, glasses or luggage. This often occurs in connection or in combination with another crime such as a fight or battery. In such contexts, however, it is more difficult to identify whether the damage to the property was intentional or whether it occurred accidentally in the context of a fight.
- Damage to a neighbour’s home – neighbour disputes are also often accompanied by the offence of damage to property. If the item in question is not the aforementioned car, it can be anything from a neighbour’s home. In practice, we have seen trees cut down, a garden doused with chemicals or a damaged swimming pool.
From our law practice
Mr Antonín contacted us after his neighbour damaged his parked car after a long-running dispute – according to the photographs we secured, the damage was deep gouges on the doors and fender and the damage exceeded tens of thousands of crowns. At first, the client had only photographs and suspected that a specific person was the perpetrator, but lacked clear procedural guidance. We helped him to properly draft the documents for a criminal complaint, recommended to provide CCTV footage and followed up with a quantification of the damage according to the workshop. The result was a quicker procedural grasp of the matter by the police and also a better position to claim compensation.
Summary
Damage to another’s property is not just a run-of-the-mill neighborhood or property dispute. In criminal law, what matters most is whether the property was someone else’s, whether the perpetrator acted intentionally, and what damage was actually caused. It is the combination of these circumstances that determines whether the matter will be treated as a criminal offence or just as a misdemeanour or civil dispute for damages. In practice, the problem is mainly one of proof: the victim often does not have timely photographs, a repair estimate, witnesses or CCTV footage. For the accused, the issue is often whether intent has been proven and whether the amount of the damage corresponds to reality. It therefore pays to act quickly, secure evidence as soon as possible and choose the right legal course of action from the outset.
Frequently Asked Questions
When is damaging someone else's property a crime and when is it just a misdemeanour?
Damage to another’s property is a criminal offence if the perpetrator intentionally damages, destroys or renders useless the property of another and causes damage of at least CZK 10 000. If the damage is less or there is no intent, it may be an offence against property, which is dealt with by the municipal authority or the police. The intention and the amount of the damage are therefore decisive.
Can negligent damage to property be prosecuted?
Usually not. Damage to property caused by negligence is not a criminal offence under the Czech Criminal Code – criminal liability arises only in the case of intentional conduct. Negligent damage to property is therefore typically dealt with as a civil claim for damages, or as an offence if the conduct was careless or in breach of legal obligations.
How does compensation for damage to an item work?
Compensation for damage to an item is determined according to the actual damage caused – i.e. the cost of repair or the value of the item before and after the damage. In some situations, the cost of an expert’s report, loss of profit or the cost of not being able to use the item may also apply. The claim can be brought in civil proceedings or in criminal proceedings as an injured party.
What should I do if I have committed the offence of damaging someone else's property?
In the case of damage to property – an offence, it is advisable to make good the damage as soon as possible and cooperate with the authorities. The municipality may impose a fine or an obligation to repair the damage. If the damage was caused unintentionally, it is important to document this (witnesses, photos, circumstances of the damage) so that the matter is not mistakenly treated as a deliberate crime.
When and how can I claim compensation for damage to other people's property?
Any owner of the damaged property can claim for damage to another’s property – compensation for damage. If the act is a criminal offence, compensation can be claimed directly in criminal proceedings by means of a so-called adhesion claim. In other cases, a civil action is brought. It is always advisable to collect evidence: photographs, repair invoices, an estimate of the damage, witness statements or a police report.