Pre-emption right of the apartment tenant and land owner

JUDr. Ondřej Preuss, Ph.D.
4. 11. 2023
7 minutes of reading
7 minutes of reading
Real Estate

The right of pre-emption of co-owners has undergone significant adjustment and reduction by the legislator in recent years. Nevertheless, we do encounter it in the Civil Code, although these are rather specific and, let’s say, rare cases. These are the pre-emption rights of tenants in newly defined housing units and also the right of landowners in relation to a building that belongs to someone else. In our article, we will take a closer look at both specific situations and add information on contractual pre-emption rights.

dva majitelé pozemku řeší předkupní právo

Chapters of the article

What does a right of first refusal generally mean?

Pre-emption is the right of the pre-emptionist to demand a preferential offer to buy the property on the same terms as the seller would sell the property to another interested party. To give a practical example – if, for example, two friends owned a house together and one had a contractual right of first refusal, then the other would not be allowed to sell their share “just because”. He would first have to offer his share to his friend on the same terms as he would offer it to a third party.

In earlier times, the right of pre-emption was automatic for co-owners, but this changed after 2020. Now, this entitlement to co-owners arises by operation of law if the co-ownership occurred as part of an inheritance and the share of one of the heirs is offered for sale within six months of the heir acquiring it (in addition, the pre-emption right does not apply if the share is offered to close relatives). In other cases, the pre-emption right must be secured by contract or it must be a specific situation described in the law.

Preemption or other unusual arrangements?

Whether youplan to buy or sell a property, there are a number of documents with legal loopholes waiting for you. Don’t risk complications. Within 48 hours we will provide you with a complete contractual and legal service – flawlessly and professionally.

Pre-emptive right of tenants of the apartment

As mentioned above, the Civil Code also provides for certain specific situations in which the right of pre-emption is also applicable, without the need to establish it contractually. One such situation is the right of pre-emption of the tenant of the apartment. However, it is exercised under very specific conditions:

  • the tenant of the apartment unit is a natural person (the right does not apply to legal persons),
  • the apartment unit was created by dividing the ownership right to the whole building into ownership rights to individual units,
  • the right of pre-emption appliesonly to the first transfer of the unit after the division of the building into units.

The above also applies to the lease of non-residential space if it was leased in connection with a flat in the same building where the above conditions occur. The right of pre-emption shall lapse if the tenant does not accept the offer within six months of its effectiveness.

The tenant’s right of pre-emption shall be activated at the moment of conclusion of the purchase contract regarding the newly created unit between the owner of the building and the foreign interested party. At such time, the building owner is obliged to offer the unit in writing to the tenant of the unit on identical terms and at the same purchase price.

As we have already stated, the tenant has six months from the effective date of the offer to exercise the right. During this period, he may accept the offer and pay the owner the stipulated purchase price. Otherwise, the right will lapse. However, if he accepts the offer, then the owner’s offer to the third party (the Civil Code refers to the third party as the “purchaser”) is extinguished. If he has even paid the purchase price to the owner, the latter must return it. The position of the ‘purchaser’ is therefore very uncertain and, in theory, he may not know for six months whether the purchase will take place or not. The offer is therefore not worthwhile for anyone who needs an apartment for immediate and permanent living.

Tip: Uncertainty in a given situation can be removed contractually, for example, if the tenant waives its pre-emption right in writing. However, do not embark on such legal modifications without consulting an attorney, as a mistake in the documentation could lead to future complications and years of litigation over the right to purchase or own the apartment.

Pre-emption right of the land owner

The Civil Code also seeks to address situations that have occurred so far where the owner of the land and the owner of the building on it are two different persons. The previous Civil Code allowed for such a regime, which gave rise to many uncertainties and legal disputes, for example in access to the property, use of the land around the house, etc.

The new Civil Code therefore introduced the principle of “superficies solo cedit”, i.e. the surface gives way to the land. This means in practice that buildings are not a separate thing. This therefore applies to land and buildings where the owner of the building and the land is the same person. However, where historically the situation described above has arisen where there are two persons, a further provision comes in to help resolve this unclear situation. It provides that the owner of land on which there is a building which is not historically part of the land and has another owner has a right of first refusal in respect of that building. The reverse is also true. The owner of such a building then has a pre-emption right to the land.

The above provision of the Civil Code is aimed at eliminating these confusing situations and at integrating ownership by one person where it makes sense.

Example:

Imagine a situation where more than one person owns land under such a regime, for example, Mr. Peter and Mr. Paul. Mrs. Eva, who owns the building, would have to offer the building to both Mr. Peter and Mr. Pavel under the pre-emption right if it were sold. However, if Mr. Petr was not interested in the building, Mr. Pavel could buy the whole building himself, still under the pre-emption right. Therefore, even if Mr Peter is not interested, Mrs Eva may not sell the building to a stranger.

The right of pre-emption in the above-mentioned form also belongs to a legal person, or perhaps to the state, which can exercise it through the State Land Office (formerly known as the Land Fund). This occurs similarly in a situation where the state owns a certain piece of land on which a foreign building is located.

Tip: The previous practice when selling a co-ownership share included the obligation to offer the co-ownership share in priority. This has not been the case for several years. What has been the historical development of this legal regulation of pre-emption rights and what rights are now left to co-owners? This is the subject of our separate article.

Contractual pre-emption right

In addition to the statutory provisions, a pre-emption right may also arise by legal agreement between two parties.However, if it is negotiated as a so-called obligatory one, it is not registered in the Land Register. The buyer of the property then has basically no chance to find out from publicly available sources whether such a right has been established or not.

If the pre-emption right is established as a so-called right in rem, then it is registered in the Land Registry.

Both of these options should be checked before any purchase of real estate. In the case of a debenture right, a clause should be included in the purchase contract in which the owner excludes the existence of a pre-emption right and this guarantee is insured by a contractual penalty.

Are you solving a similar problem?

Dostupný advokát team of online lawyers will solve it for you.

Real Estate Purchase or Sale

We provide a complete package of legal services related to real estate sales and purchases, including reservation contracts and escrow services. We will also help you with all tax and land registry issues. Our work is fast and accurate, ensuring a worry-free transaction. You’re also welcome to pay after services are provided.

Preset Prices
When you order, you know what you will get and how much it will cost.
Online and in person
We handle everything online or in person at one of our 4 offices.
We Work Fast
We handle 8 out of 10 requests within 2 working days.
Experienced Team
We have specialists for every field of law.

Has this content helped you? Give it a rating

No rating yet. Be first to rate and help others.

Author of the article

JUDr. Ondřej Preuss, Ph.D.

Ondřej is the attorney who came up with the idea of providing legal services online. He's been earning his living through legal services for more than 10 years. He especially likes to help clients who may have given up hope in solving their legal issues at work, for example with real estate transfers or copyright licenses.

Education
  • Law, Ph.D, Pf UK in Prague
  • Law, L’université Nancy-II, Nancy
  • Law, Master’s degree (Mgr.), Pf UK in Prague
  • International Territorial Studies (Bc.), FSV UK in Prague

Reviews of the Dostupný advokát service

Recenze služby
Economist

Jan Sekanina, Prague

My grandparents wanted to give me an apartment, but I was extremely busy at the time and couldn’t afford to put any time into finding out what I needed to do. I also had no idea how to get the transfer of ownership handled at the Land Registry. Dostupný advokát arranged everything for me, and the apartment transfer was legally arranged with no issues. Thank you and thumbs up!

Recenze služby
Landlord

PhDr. Helena Hoffmanová, Prague

I lease and sublease properties professionally and have been working with Dostupný advokát regularly long term. I especially appreciate their reliability. I also admire the flexibility and professionalism of their online legal service. But what I value most is that they are always on top of the latest news. With Dostupný advokát I can feel confident because I know that my business is always covered.

Recenze služby
FinTechCowboys.cz review

Lucia Tóthová, Prague

We chose the premium package because it promised a fast reply within 24 hours, and we needed help quickly. A few hours after sending our order, Dostupný advokát called us. After discussing our issue and agreeing on the next steps, we felt confident in how the whole procedure would go since we had never experienced it before. We appreciate their patience.

View All Testimonials

You could also be interested in

We can also solve your legal problem

In person and online. Just choose the appropriate service or opt for an independent consultation when you are unsure.

Google reviews
4.9
Facebook reviews
5.0
5 200+ people follow our Facebook
140+ people follow our X account (Twitter)
140+ people follow our LinkedIn
 
We can discuss your problem online and in person

You can find us in 4 regional towns

Quick contacts

+420 775 420 436
(Mo–Fri: 8–18)
We regularly comment on events and news for the media